The simple truth is that the quality of most self-published books is terrible.  And unfortunately this fact is bringing down the entire culture around self-publishing, as people don’t trust a self-published book is any good.  At the same time, you can find people reading a book and saying, “I can’t believe this is self-published,” both happy to have discovered something new and lamenting the fact that so many prospective writers have to resort to self-publishing when ignored by traditional publishers.

Getting published is enormously difficult – mainstream publishers aren’t very adventurous and choose “marketable” books, and small presses – which are more adventurous – don’t have the money to put out a large number of books a year.  In this climate, self-publishing makes perfect sense.

The Literati’s View

The main people who complain about the value of self-published books are people who might scoff at the value of certain mainstream writers as well.  A writer like Dean Koontz himself would not proclaim himself to be writing “literature” but he is hugely successful.  A number of self-published writers are those who are attempting to write Koontz-style thrillers, so by nature they are not heavy literature.

If there’s any complaint about many self-published books it’s just this: they are unsuccessful attempts at mainstream books, rather than more literary books that were too experimental or too genre-bending to find a traditional publisher.  What happens with the writers of these types of books is that they don’t consider self-publishing, as self-publishing has a bad rap and reputation.  If self-publishing were to become a valid route for all writers then self-publishing would shed some of it’s bad reputation.  As time goes on, and there are more success stories, like Frank Daniels or Will Clarke, the more self-publishing will be seen as an important and legitimate part of the publishing world.

Non-fiction Self-Publishing

Of course, this mainly has to do with fiction self-publishing, as there are numerous self-publishing success stories for non-fiction titles and ebooks.  Non-fiction just doesn’t have the same stigma as fiction titles, and generally non-fiction does not have to be as well-written – or its writing deficiencies are not as glaring.  The reason that self-publishing has such a bad rap is because of the quality of self-published fiction.

As it says in the Self-Published Review’s brief manifesto, one of the major purposes of this site is to improve the culture surrounding self-publishing.  So listen up authors: the only way to improve the state of self-publishing is for authors to take care with every book they put out.  Don’t just publish because it’s free – because you can.  Put some extra money and time into the book to get editorial criticism and creating a cover that doesn’t shout out “self-published.”

Every bad self-published book damages the reputation of self-publishing on the whole.  So be honest with yourself: did you get all those rejection letters because editors and agents are small-minded or because the book truly needs a lot of work?  If you’re going to expect readers to sit down for hours with your book, you should take the time to make the book as polished as possible.

Get an Editorial Review | Get Amazon Sales & Reviews | Get Edited | Get Beta Readers | Enter the SPR Book Awards | Other Marketing Services